Does god have to allow evil to exist so we can have free will?

People often ask,  "If god exists why does he allow so much evil in the world.  The standard religious apologetic  is that god has to allow man to do evil  otherwise man wouldn't have free will and would just be an automaton.  This apologetic makes the false assumption that free will is absolute when it most certainly is not. I cannot free will myself to walk through walls, appear on Mars and return, look like Jessica Alba, stop feeling pain, and so on but no one would deny that I have free will despite those restrictions on it.

By the same token, assuming god exists, he could prevent us from doing evil and we would still have free will to decide who we love, which job we take, what kind of house to live in, what to eat, what kind of car to drive, and so on. Not being able to do evil would not stop us from having limited free will just as we do now.

The idea that god allows evil to exist so that humans can have free will is obviously bunk, a cheap, false excuse to attempt to justify an all powerful and all knowing god that unjustifiably allows evil to exist.

"Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.

Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.

Is he both able and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?

Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?”

There is a long list of evil things in the world, only god's nonexistence could excuse his inaction.

The essence of morality is "do whatever you want, but harm no one".

Gayness is moral by definition as it harms no one.

Denying gays equal rights is by definition immoral as it harms innocent people.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why gayness can never be eliminated or even reduced in the human race

Male testicle size is often indicative of whether males and females of a specie are monogamous or promiscuous.  In male animals with typically small testicles matings tend to be monogamous.  In animals with very large testicles couples tend to be more promiscuous.  Male human testicles are in the medium size range which is a biological indicator that human male and female couples tend to be somewhere in the middle between monogamous and promiscuous.  Human couples aren't evolved for exclusive monogamous relationships. Some months ago, a  JMG reader  asked me if I had any ideas about some  shocking behavior between gay and straight men he'd witnessed in the 1950's.  Apparently a gang of heterosexual men would seek out a group of gay men.  The heterosexual men would force the gay men to perform fellatio on them in an alley-way and during the...orgy(?) the heterosexual men would be punching and kicking the men performing fellatio on them telling them things like "You wo
Read more

How I Suppressed And Then Accepted My Attraction to Males

 I  had moved away from home at 19 and started school  in MooseJaw.  I don't  recall exactly how it came to pass, but I was at this guy's place (let's call him Dave)  and we talked for an hour or two.  Or I should say mostly he talked and I listened.  He went on and on about how much he couldn't stand gays and talked about him and his friends going to a gay bar and beating up some gays and yelling at them "And tell  all  your friends!".  He also went on and about a friend of his who had told Dave he was gay.  "He's not gay.  I told him "You're not gay, you're  just confused..." perhaps as much trying to convince himself as me. At the time I was feeling ashamed and horrified by my attraction to males and a  couple of years earlier I had found that by vehemently thinking about how angry gays made me and how much I hated and rejected them I could push awareness of those attractions out of my mind and convince myself I had no attraction
Read more

A Zygote or a Fetus Is Not a Person

Many anti-choice people will insist that a pregnancy at any stage is a "person" or "human".  This is manifestly untrue.  Let's take a zygote, for example.   When we think of what a person is we think of certain features, abilities, and characteristics.  A person can move, think,  feel pain, feel pleasurable sensations,  eat,  laugh,  love, hate,  and  make plans for the future (even if the future is only the next few seconds).  By that universally accepted standard a zygote is in no way a person - it can do none of that, it is capable of nothing we think of a person being able to do.  Now I hear some of you angrily insisting a zygote is human and I'll grant you that it's human in the same sense that one of my fingernail clippings is human - it originates from a human,  it is of a human, it is human matter, but it is NOT a human being, it is NOT a person.  A zygote merits no more consideration than a mosquito biting you does,  the destruction of a zygote
Read more